History
Our Beginnings
For Lutherans scattered in and around Sheboygan Falls, Reverend F. Steinbach would visit weekly from Trinity Lutheran Church in Sheboygan. Services were held each Sunday afternoon in various homes in the village. These early mission pastors planted the seeds of what was to become our congregation.
Our first church building was constructed in 1858 and served the congregation until 1890, when a new building was built to accommodate the growing congregation.
A second building was constructed in 1890 and served until 1915.
St. Paul Lutheran built a new home at 621 Broadway in downtown Sheboygan Falls, where the congregation worshiped until 1994.
St. Paul Lutheran moved to our current location at 730 County Road PPP, Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin. This facility continues to serve as the home base for our growing congregation and ministries.
On September 30, 2004, the 150th Anniversary Celebration Committee met for the first time. January 16, 2005, was chosen for the kickoff weekend, celebrated under the theme: "St. Paul's Lutheran Church, 150 Years of Blessings — Where Everybody is Somebody and Jesus Christ is Lord."
Ministry History
St. Paul started a 3 and 4-year-old Preschool in 1986, housed in the Education Center. In October 1997, it was moved to its present location in the 200 wing of the new facility. Over the years the program has expanded to serve families by offering two sessions of 3-year-old Preschool, two sessions of 4K, and Child Care, which was added September 1, 2009.
St. Paul started The Gathering Place in April 2008, caring for persons with memory loss one day a week in the 100 wing of the church. In April 2009, a second day was added each week. In December 2011, a third day opened. A fourth day was added at a satellite location, Good Shepherd Lutheran Church, in June 2017.
Our Shepherds
Below is a record of the pastors who have faithfully served St. Paul Lutheran Church throughout our history. We are grateful for each shepherd God has placed among us.
Mission Pastors
Reverend F. Steinbach
1855 – 1857 | Mission Pastor
Visited Sheboygan Falls weekly from Trinity Lutheran Church in Sheboygan, holding services in homes throughout the village. One of the founding shepherds of our congregation.
Reverend Daniel Stecher
1858 | Mission Pastor
Replaced Reverend Steinbach and helped the congregation grow to the point where they could call their first full-time resident pastor.
Resident Pastors – 1858 to 1938
Reverend Ernest Henry Rolf
1858 – 1860 | Pastor
St. Paul's first full-time resident pastor.
Reverend Edmund Multanowski
1860 – 1862 | Pastor
Reverend Friedrich Ottman
1863 – 1872 | Pastor
Also served as pastor to the Plymouth congregation simultaneously.
Reverend J. Jacob Hoffmann
1873 – 1878 | Pastor
Reverend John M. Hieber
1879 – 1894 | Pastor
Reverend George Wildermuth
1894 – 1913 | Pastor
Served 19 years at St. Paul, also serving St. Thomas Lutheran Church and Bethany Lutheran Church in Kohler.
Reverend John Biehusen
1913 – 1939 | Pastor
Faithfully served our congregation for 26 years. Described as "one of the best known and most beloved clergyman in the county."
Pastors – 1939 to Present
Reverend Edward W. Albertin
1939 – 1976 | Senior Pastor • 1977 – 1982 | Pastor Emeritus
Served our congregation faithfully for nearly four decades, witnessing remarkable growth from approximately 300 communicant members in 1939 to over 1,000 by 1980. He became Pastor Emeritus in 1977 and continued to serve until his death on January 19, 1982. The Albertin Dedicated Endowment Fund was established in his honor.
Reverend Alfred F. Nicolaus
1959 – 1964 | Assistant Pastor
Reverend Charles Borcherding
1965 – 1969 | Associate Pastor
Reverend Leroy C. Rittenbach
1969 – 1973 | Associate Pastor
Reverend Paul W. Krause
1973 – 1976 | Associate Pastor • 1977 – 1980 | Senior Pastor
Became Senior Pastor in January 1977 when Pastor Albertin began serving as Pastor Emeritus.
Reverend Dale A. Hauser, Jr.
1981 – 1984 | Associate Pastor
Reverend Randall F. Mueller
1981 – 1987 | Associate Pastor
Vicar John Rutz
1985 | Vicar
Reverend Richard Nack
1986 – 1997 | Assistant Pastor
Reverend Donald E. Hasse
1987 – 2000 | Senior Pastor • 2000 – 2004 | Associate Pastor • 2004 – Present | Pastor Emeritus
Served our congregation faithfully as Senior Pastor for 13 years before transitioning roles. Pastor Hasse was ordained into the holy ministry in 1965 and brought deep pastoral experience to St. Paul. He was named Pastor Emeritus in 2004 and continues to serve and support our congregation to this day.
Reverend Thomas Gudmundson
1998 – 2000 | Associate Pastor • 2000 – 2021 | Senior Pastor • 2021 – Present | Pastor Emeritus
Answered a call to St. Paul in 1998 as Associate Pastor. In 2000, he and Pastor Hasse exchanged duties, and Reverend Gudmundson became our Senior Pastor, a role he served with faithfulness and dedication for over 20 years. He was named Pastor Emeritus in 2021 and continues to serve and support our congregation.
Reverend Thomas W. Vanderbilt
2001 – 2004 | Associate Pastor
Reverend Mark Janzen
2005 – 2018 | Associate Pastor
Installed as Associate Pastor of Care Ministries on January 22, 2005.
Reverend Kyle Backhaus
2018 – Present | Senior Pastor
Currently serving as our Senior Pastor, leading our congregation in its mission of Connecting People to Christ.
Reverend Rob Schrader
2021 – 2024 | Associate Pastor
Reverend Adam Wolfe
2025 – Present | Associate Pastor
Currently serving alongside Pastor Backhaus in leading our congregation.
